1 The Significance of Paleotopography
Marin K. Clark
ABSTRACT ........................................................ 1
INTRODUCTION .................................................... 1
DEFINITIONS AND SCALES OF TOPOGRAPHY, ELEVATION, AND RELIEF ..... 2
MEASUREMENTS FROM PALEOALTIMETRY METHODS ........................ 2
SHAPING THE LAND SURFACE: RELATIONSHIPS AMONG CLIMATE,
EROSION AND TECTONICS THAT DICTATE MEAN ELEVATION ............. 3
Paleorelief vs. paleoelevation .............................. 4
TOPOGRAPHY CHANGE PREDICTED BY TECTONIC MODELS .................. 5
Tibetan Plateau: widespread contraction ..................... 6
Basin and Range Province: widespread extension ............. 11
DISCUSSION ..................................................... 15
SUMMARY ........................................................ 16
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................ 16
REFERENCES ..................................................... 17
2 Stable Isotope-Based Paleoaltimetry:
Theory and Validation
David B. Rowley
ABSTRACT ....................................................... 23
INTRODUCTION ................................................... 23
STABLE ISOTOPE-BASED PALEOALTIMETRY ............................ 26
ATMOSPHERIC THERMODYNAMICS OF OXYGEN AND HYDROGEN ISOTOPE-
BASED ESTIMATES OF ELEVATION FROM OROGRAPHIC PRECIPITATION ..... 26
THE MODEL ...................................................... 27
MODEL VERSUS EMPIRICAL FITTING OF DATA ......................... 36
DATA-MODEL COMPARISONS ......................................... 38
SURFACE WATERS ................................................. 40
CONCLUSIONS .................................................... 49
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................ 50
REFERENCES ..................................................... 50
3 Paleoelevation Reconstruction using Pedogenic
Carbonates
Jay Quade, Carmala Garzione, John Eiler
ABSTRACT ....................................................... 53
INTRODUCTION ................................................... 54
DEPENDENCE OF THE ISOTOPIC COMPOSITION OF RAINFALL
ON ELEVATION ................................................. 56
MODERN PEDOGENIC CARBONATES .................................... 58
Pedogenic carbonate formation .............................. 58
The oxygen isotopic composition of Holocene pedogenic
carbonate ................................................ 59
Soil temperature considerations ............................ 60
Evaluation of aridity ...................................... 61
Elevation variation in the δ18Osc value of pedogenic
carbonate ................................................ 64
PALEO-ELEVATION ESTIMATES USING CARBONATE "CLUMPED ISOTOPE"
PALEOTHERMOMETRY ............................................. 67
Principles, methods and instrumentation .................... 68
Advantages and disadvantages ............................... 69
DIAGENESIS ..................................................... 70
PALEOSOL RECORDS OF PALEOELEVATION CHANGE: CASE STUDIES ........ 71
Paleoelevation reconstruction of the Bolivian Altiplano .... 71
Results from clumped isotope thermometry ................... 76
Paleoatimetry of southern Tibet and the Himalaya ........... 78
CONCLUDING REMARKS ............................................. 83
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ................................................ 83
REFERENCES ..................................................... 84
4 Stable Isotope Paleoaltimetry in Orogenic Belts-
The Silicate Record in Surface and Crustal
Geological Archives
Andreas Mulch, C. Page Chamberlain
ABSTRACT ....................................................... 89
INTRODUCTION ................................................... 89
STABLE ISOTOPE PALEOALTIMETRY AND MOUNTAIN BUILDING
PROCESSES .................................................... 90
Quantitative paleoelevation estimates as boundary
conditions for climate models ............................ 90
Quantitative paleoelevation estimates as boundary
conditions for tectonic models ........................... 91
What can the geodynamic and tectonic modeling community
expect from future stable isotope paleoaltimetry
studies? ................................................. 93
STABLE ISOTOPE PALEOALTIMETRY USING SILICATE PROXIES ........... 93
Cherts and clay minerals ................................... 93
A historical note on stable isotope paleoaltimetry ......... 94
Shear zone silicates as paleoelevation proxies ............. 98
The coupled basin-detachment approach ..................... 101
APPLICATIONS OF STABLE ISOTOPE PALEOALTIMETRY ................. 102
Tracking of orogenic rain shadows ......................... 102
Reconstructing paleo-river slopes ......................... 105
Reconstructing paleoelevation in eroded mountain ranges ... 108
CONCLUSIONS AND FUTURE DIRECTIONS ............................. 110
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................... 114
REFERENCES .................................................... 114
5 Paleoaltimetry from Stable Isotope Compositions
of Fossils
Matthew J. Kohn, David L. Dettman
ABSTRACT ...................................................... 119
INTRODUCTION .................................................. 119
LINKS BETWEEN ELEVATION AND OXYGEN ISOTOPE COMPOSITIONS ....... 120
Isotopic lapse rates ...................................... 120
Monsoons .................................................. 122
MATERIALS AND METHODS ......................................... 122
Choosing a problem ........................................ 122
Vertebrate fossils ........................................ 124
Invertebrate fossils ...................................... 128
EXAMPLES AND APPLICATIONS ..................................... 134
Tibetan Plateau ........................................... 134
Cascades .................................................. 138
Late Cretaceous and Paleogene Rockies ..................... 142
DISCUSSION .................................................... 145
Lapse rates ............................................... 145
Paleoclimate .............................................. 146
Potential improvements to paleoaltimetry .................. 146
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................... 148
REFERENCES .................................................... 148
6 A Review of Paleotemperature-Lapse Rate Methods
for Estimating Paleoelevation from Fossil Floras
Herbert W. Meyer
ABSTRACT ...................................................... 155
INTRODUCTION .................................................. 155
REVIEW OF METHODOLOGIES FOR ESTIMATING PALEOELEVATION ......... 156
Paleotemperature estimates from fossil floras ............. 156
Lapse rate methodologies for estimating paleoelevation .... 158
Seasonal variations of temperature: Effects on vegetation
distribution and lapse rates ............................ 162
Other variables ........................................... 163
APPLICATIONS .................................................. 165
Late Eocene Florissant flora .............................. 165
Western Tertiary floras ................................... 165
DISCUSSION .................................................... 168
CONCLUSIONS ................................................... 169
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................... 169
REFERENCES .................................................... 169
7 Paleoaltimetry: A Review of Thermodynamic Methods
Chris E. Forest
ABSTRACT ...................................................... 173
INTRODUCTION .................................................. 173
USING MOIST STATIC ENERGY ..................................... 175
SPATIAL DISTRIBUTION OF MOIST STATIC ENERGY ................... 176
Theoretical constraints ................................... 176
Surface observations of moist static energy ............... 179
Moist static energy versus mean annual temperature ........ 180
RELEVANT PALEOBOTANICAL WORK .................................. 181
Previous physiognomic methods for estimating
paleoclimate ............................................ 182
ESTIMATING PALEOCLIMATE ....................................... 182
Data ...................................................... 182
Data analysis ............................................. 184
Results of physiognomy/climate analysis ................... 186
TOTAL EXPECTED ERROR IN PALEOALTITUDE ......................... 188
APPLICATIONS OF THERMODYNAMIC METHODS ......................... 190
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS ....................................... 190
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................... 191
REFERENCES .................................................... 191
8 Paleoelevation Measurement on the Basis of
Vesicular Basalts
Dork Sahagian, Alex Proussevitch
ABSTRACT ...................................................... 195
INTRODUCTION .................................................. 196
CALCULATING PALEOATMOSPHERIC PRESSURE ......................... 198
NECESSARY CONDITIONS AND ASSUMPTIONS .......................... 198
MEASURING VESICLE SIZE DISTRIBUTIONS .......................... 202
TESTING THE TECHNIQUE ......................................... 203
SENSITIVITY ANALYSIS AND POTENTIAL SOURCES OF ERROR ........... 204
COMPARISON WITH OTHER PALEOELEVATION PROXIES .................. 207
APPLICATION TO THE UPLIFT HISTORY OF THE COLORADO PLATEAU ..... 207
CONCLUSIONS ................................................... 211
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................... 211
REFERENCES .................................................... 211
9 Stomatal Frequency Change Over Altitudinal
Gradients: Prospects for Paleoaltimetry
Lenny L.R. Kouwenberg, Wolfram M. Kürschner, Jennifer C. McElwain
ABSTRACT ...................................................... 215
INTRODUCTION .................................................. 216
NEW RESULTS ................................................... 217
Leaf morphology data ...................................... 217
CLIMATIC PARAMETERS, GAS EXCHANGE AND STOMATAL RESPONSE ....... 223
Changes in abiotic factors with altitude and direct
effects on stomatal density and initiation .............. 224
Effects of climatic changes with altitude on air-leaf
gas exchange ............................................ 227
APPLICATION OF STOMATAL FREQUENCY AS A PALEO-ALTIMETER:
RECOMMENDATIONS AND LIMITATIONS ............................. 230
Stomatal frequency techniques ............................. 230
Constraints on the selection of method and material ....... 231
Sources of error and quantification of uncertainty ........ 232
CONCLUSIONS ................................................... 234
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................... 235
REFERENCES .................................................... 235
APPENDIX 1 .................................................... 239
MATERIAL AND METHODS ........................................ 239
Collected material ........................................ 239
Light experiment .......................................... 239
Temperature experiment .................................... 239
Processing and analytical methods ......................... 239
APPENDIX 2 .................................................... 241
APPLICATION MANUAL .......................................... 241
10 Thermochronologic Approaches to Paleotopography
Peter W. Reiners
ABSTRACT ...................................................... 243
INTRODUCTION .................................................. 243
Thermochronology .......................................... 244
Erosion and paleotopography ............................... 245
Cooling-age or cooling-history variations and
paleotopography ......................................... 245
BEDROCK-BASED APPROACHES ...................................... 246
Topographic bending of isotherms .......................... 246
The House et al. (1998, 2001) Sierra Nevada studies ....... 249
Spectral approaches ....................................... 251
Other bedrock-based approaches to understanding
topographic change ...................................... 254
Caveats in interpreting spatial patterns of cooling ages
and cooling histories ................................... 258
DETRITAL APPROACHES ........................................... 260
SUMMARY ....................................................... 263
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................... 263
REFERENCES .................................................... 263
11 Terrestrial Cosmogenic Nuclides as Paleoaltimetric
Proxies
Catherine A. Riihimaki, Julie С Libarkin
ABSTRACT ...................................................... 269
INTRODUCTION .................................................. 269
PRODUCTION OF COSMOGENIC NUCLIDES IN ROCK ..................... 271
COSMOGENIC-NUCLIDEPALEOALTIMETRY .............................. 272
POTENTIAL SOURCES OF ERROR IN COSMOGENIC-NUCLIDE
PALEOALTIMETRY .............................................. 274
CONCLUSIONS ................................................... 277
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS ............................................... 277
REFERENCES .................................................... 277
|